### When Green's theorem applies

Green's theorem provides another way to calculate \begin{align*} \dlint \end{align*} that you can use instead of calculating the line integral directly. However, some common mistakes involve using Green's theorem to attempt to calculate line integrals where it doesn't even apply.

First, Green's theorem works **only** for the case where $\dlc$
is a simple closed curve.
If $\dlc$ is an
open curve, please
*don't even think* about using Green's theorem.

If you think of the idea of Green's theorem in terms of circulation, you won't make this mistake. Green's theorem converts the line integral to a double integral of the microscopic circulation. The double integral is taken over the region $\dlr$ inside the path. Only closed paths have a region $\dlr$ inside them. The idea of circulation makes sense only for closed paths. (And the line integral represents circulation around the region only if is simple.)

So if you are asked to compute the integral
\begin{align*}
\int_\dlc y\, dx + xy \, dy
\end{align*}
where $\dlc$ is the line from $(0,1)$ to $(1,1)$, can you use Green's
theorem? **No**, because $\dlc$ is an open curve.

You could, for example, use Green's theorem to compute \begin{align*} \int_\dlc y\, dx + xy \, dy \end{align*} where $\dlc$ is the counterclockwise unit circle.

Second, Green's theorem can be used only for vector fields in
**two** dimensions, such as the $\dlvf(x,y)= (y, xy)$ of the
above example. It **cannot** be used for vector fields in three
dimensions. So, don't bother with Green's theorem if you are given an
integral like
\begin{align*}
\int_\dlc z\, dx + xy \, dy - yz \, dz
\end{align*}
even if $\dlc$ is a closed path.

Why a whole page just to stress these simple ideas? Because students frequently under pressure try to use Green's theorem when it doesn't apply. Maybe now that you've read this warning, you'll resist that temptation.

#### Thread navigation

##### Multivariable calculus

- Previous: The idea behind Green's theorem
- Next: Other ways of writing Green's theorem

##### Math 2374

#### Notation systems

#### Similar pages

- The idea behind Green's theorem
- Green's theorem with multiple boundary components
- Calculating the formula for circulation per unit area
- A path-dependent vector field with zero curl
- The idea of the curl of a vector field
- Subtleties about curl
- The components of the curl
- Line integrals as circulation
- Other ways of writing Green's theorem
- Using Green's theorem to find area
- More similar pages