Home > rant > Thought experiment: witness protection program

Thought experiment: witness protection program

April 4, 2012

I’m often accused by my family members of having no imagination.

I really don’t think that’s fair, I think it’s more that they have outrageous amounts of imagination, and I’m normal. My husband will say something at the dinner table along the lines of, “hey I was thinking about what it would be like to live on a planet that’s attached to another planet by a weird system of ropes,” and without skipping a beat one of my sons will start asking questions: “Are they going straight up in the air or slanted? Can you climb up to the other planet? How far away is it?”. Pretty soon they are, and I’m not kidding, arguing about how thick the ropes are and the question of traveling between the planets and the different civilizations that would evolve on these two conjoined spheres. I’m an observer.

When one of them says something directly to me along the lines of, “mom, what if we lived on a spaceship going to Mars and we could only eat a liquid diet and there were no books, only videogames?”, I am usually pretty stumped (fake example, I just made it up, but you get what I mean). It just doesn’t make sense to me, and I’m constantly going back to one of the assumptions and asking why – why no books? Can’t we get books if we have so much technology? This is when my kids roll their eyes and walk back to their room.

I can’t help it, I’m just a practical-minded person. I want to solve problems but I want those problems to make sense.

In pure defense of my own ability to imagine, I came up with the following thought experiment. For some reason, which doesn’t matter (although it can be fun to come up with ridiculous reasons), we are all put into the witness protection program, and have to move to a tiny little town in the south or the midwest and we have to blend in with the townspeople, and figure out how to make a living and how to make a home. Or at the very least, if we don’t blend in exactly, we have to come up with a good story to explain our eccentricities, and it can’t be, “we’re in the witness protection program!”.

The first question is how we can make a living. I usually imagine waitressing at first, then learning how to be a car mechanic. I think of being a car mechanic as the coolest, nerdiest thing you can count on being able to do in a small town. Plus I love those jumpsuits with the grease stains, I would totally rock my jumpsuit, kinda like these guys:

My husband is a bit harder to place. He’s kind of a huge math nerd, with no actual practical skills, so the best we’ve come up with is that he can be the guy who goes around to people’s houses and helps them with their computer set-ups. But as people are getting better at computers, and as wireless systems are getting easier to set up, this plan is becoming increasingly weak.

Then there’s the issue of his Dutch accent. The idea that our story is that we’ve just moved like 60 miles, so we’re supposed to be heartland Americans, and the accent totally messes up that story. Sometimes (in my mind of course) I make him mute, other times we explain it with some weird speech impediment or maybe a stroke. I know it’s ridiculous, but it’s a toughie!

Finally, there are my kids. They are going to have to play along with the story too, but the problem there is that they’ve been raised (intentionally) to be pretty smart-assed. I’m trying to imagine them going to some random school and not giving away that they’re from Manhattan, watch the Colbert Report every night, and have strong opinions about the GOP race (and those opinions are not positive). Put on top of that the atheism thing, and I’m getting worried. I haven’t spent enough time in little towns (say, in Iowa) to really know how weird that would be, but I’m guessing pretty obviously not-from-around-here weird.

This is one of my favorite dinner topics, I suggest you try it.

Categories: rant
  1. April 4, 2012 at 7:02 am

    In every small town everywhere there is a family who are considered freaks. The hippies, the religious fanatics, the shut-ins, the drunks, the misfits what have you. Your cover would be you’re just the weirdos of which we have plenty in the midwest. They don’t blend in but they blend in by just being. Every town has eccentric people and they are even more eccentric than eccentric city people because they aren’t part of a community weirdos that they moved to the city to find. These are the true unadulterated bonified freaks and original thinkers I am willing to argue that.

    Like

  2. Heather Russell's avatar
    Heather Russell
    April 4, 2012 at 6:13 pm

    Got to live in two small towns in the process of trying to hang on in academia. First I lived in Stillwater, OK. Then it was Bowling Green, KY. In both places I found great people and great amenities. In Stillwater, I joined a fantastic book club, a food co-op, and CSA that had produce I remember fondly. I had some of the most progressive friends I have ever had in Stillwater, and I live in Berkeley now! There was even an ongoing progressive film and discussion series on campus that helped shape many of my views. The woman who ran the book club used to say that it really isn’t true that midwestern people are more conservative. My experience backs that up, though I don’t know why they keep electing Republicans.

    In Bowling Green, I used frequent a bakery with delicious breads and pizzas and people who came to practice mountain dulcimer music. The yoga school we went to in Bowling Green had excellent classes and the teachers were like family. The CSA we joined wasn’t as good,but there was another farmer couple who I ordered vegetables from based on their weekly email. They had some of the best greens and tomatoes ever and like my OK CSA farmer, were very innovative in their organic farming techniques.Our home in Bowling Green was filled with beautiful antique furniture from a huge market nearby…

    There are good people and good things everywhere.

    Like

  3. Larry Headlund's avatar
    Larry Headlund
    April 5, 2012 at 8:34 am

    Why not just say you husband is Dutch? Immigrants end up in small town middle America too. Or if you prefer a more exotic story, he was born in a small town in PA/ND/State_far_enough_way which was settled exclusively by Dutch and they kept their language. Could be true. My grandmother was born in Pennsylvania and spoke Swedish and English with a strong accent and my mother, born in a different part of PA, spoke only Polish until she started school. Those of the right age will remember Lawence Welk, born in ND and with a Russian-German accent in public.

    Like

  4. Tara's avatar
    Tara
    April 5, 2012 at 11:00 am

    Thank you, Heather Russell! I live in Indianapolis and Cathy, you and your clan would be most welcome and accepted here 🙂

    Like

  1. No trackbacks yet.
Comments are closed.